G-7 Splits Hurt Investor Confidence as Ministers Seek Exit Plan
Group of Seven finance ministers and central bankers meet on the edge of the map today, with their policies all over it.
As they gather 195 miles south of the Arctic Circle in Iqaluit, Canada, officials are seeking more unity on bank regulation after unilateral steps by the U.K. and U.S. The end of collaboration, forged during the financial crisis, may soon spread to monetary and fiscal policies as economies exit their recessions at different speeds.
The unpredictability of policy and politics has JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Standard Chartered Bank warning investor confidence may suffer, potentially curtailing demand for riskier assets such as stocks. The Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index had its biggest weekly advance last month since October 2008 as speculation mounted China would act to curb inflation and U.S. President Barack Obama proposed limiting the size and proprietary risk-taking of large banks.
Countries are moving “from synchronous to divergent financial policies,” said Stephen Jen, a money manager at London-based hedge fund BlueGold Capital Management LLP, who predicts the dollar will outperform the euro as U.S. interest rates rise faster. “For the asset markets, policy risks will become increasingly more important than economic risks.”
Dog-Sledding
To bring policies of industrialized countries closer together, Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty, who chairs the two-day meeting starting tonight, is isolating G-7 officials, including U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner and European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet, in a former whaling and fur-trading outpost that is now the capital of Canada’s northernmost territory, Nunavut.
Officials will be offered the chance to go dog-sledding as well as have a fireside chat about the future of the G-7. Other topics set to be discussed include currencies, fiscal policies, aiding Haiti and financial reform.
The town of just over 6,000 people, where pick-up trucks share the roads with snowmobiles, has an average temperature in February of 29 degrees Celsius below zero (minus 20 degrees Fahrenheit). Wind chills sometimes bring that down to as cold as minus 50 degrees Celsius, freezing exposed skin within minutes.
Political Pressure
“Different countries have taken different steps,” Flaherty said in a Jan. 29 interview in Davos. “It’s time we have a conversation about that and coordinate more. I understand the political pressures some are facing.”
Efforts by Canada to narrow differences come as its bank executives call for more certainty and uniformity in regulations. Canada’s five largest banks — Royal Bank of Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia, Bank of Montreal and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce — are all among North America’s 20 largest banks by assets and largely escaped the credit crisis. Unlike the U.S. and Europe, Canada didn’t require a bailout of its banking industry.
“We have concerns about what appears to be a lack of unanimity and consistency regarding financial sector reform and the unintended consequences of individual policies,” Royal Bank Chief Executive Officer Gordon Nixon, 53, said in an e-mail. “I would urge G-7 countries to address the root causes and work towards a regulatory model that finds the right balance between risk and reward while enabling the banking industry to not only grow but serve as a catalyst for economic growth.”
Divergences
Five months after the Group of 20 pledged to “raise standards together,” the U.K. is imposing a one-time 50 percent tax on bank bonuses that France wants to mimic. As well as trying to revamp the shape of financial companies in a push others aren’t following, Obama is also placing a new bank levy that Flaherty won’t match. Europe and North America are already at odds over whether to tax financial speculation.
Divergences could slow the push for international regulation and create loopholes for banks to take advantage of, said Barry Eichengreen, a University of California at Berkeley economist.
“On bank reform there is undesirable splintering when they need to work in synch and quickly,” said Eichengreen.
Politics may help explain the targeting of banks as elections near in the U.S. and U.K., said Alex Barrett, global head of client research at Standard Chartered in London. Obama announced his plan to rein-in banks the same week his Democratic party lost a Senate seat in Massachusetts.
‘Source of Volatility’
Where the fear of political intervention was once an “intangible uneasiness” in the markets of emerging nations, now it will be a “significant source of volatility” for investors in richer countries, Barrett said, identifying protectionism and currency depreciations as looming risks.
After reviving economies from recession, fiscal policies may also upset markets and economies, as governments either struggle to cut ballooning sovereign debt or try to pay for social programs by raising taxes on companies, which then can’t invest, said Bruce Kasman, chief economist at JPMorgan Chase in New York.
European stocks plunged the most in two months yesterday on concern Portugal, Spain and Greece will have difficulty paring their budget deficits. Meantime, Obama’s budget last week included plans to spend $100 billion in additional stimulus measures and take in an extra $400 billion from companies.
“There is a near-term risk that policy uncertainty weighs on sentiment and tempers the shift from retrenchment now underway,” said Kasman.
Fragility
Having surged 80 percent in 2009, China’s benchmark Shanghai Composite Index has fallen 8.6 percent this year as the government starts to restrain credit growth after its economy grew the quickest since 2007 in the fourth quarter and inflation rose the most in 13 months in December.
“Global growth could easily be choked off if policy makers prematurely withdraw fiscal and monetary policy support,” said Andrew Cates, an economist at UBS AG in Singapore. “Investors have taken note of this fragility.”
Any disparities would be a marked change from the crisis period when the decision of policy makers to cut interest rates to record lows, spend more than $2 trillion in fiscal stimulus and bail out banks including Citigroup Inc. buoyed markets.
BlueGold’s Jen is now betting on a policy split emerging among the major economies. He says the U.S. Federal Reserve may offset budgetary stimulus by tightening monetary policy while the European Central Bank keeps its benchmark rate low as investors force governments to slash spending. In Asia, he expects Japan to maintain monetary and fiscal expansions and China to cut back on both fronts.
“Such a divergence in policy mixes will be a source of volatility and a propellant of new trends in asset markets,” Jen said.
Filed under: technology by Pascal
Comments Off